Published November 1, 2026 in Market Update

Southern York is still moving fast, even with rates above 7%

By Erin Kelly
Real estate, Greater York, Hanover & Southern York County

Rates are up. Buyers are more payment-sensitive. And yet, if you own a home near the Maryland line, the market is still moving faster than most people expect. Here's what the numbers actually say for the three months ending August 31, 2026.

The rate reality

Realtor.com reported that mortgage rates topped 7% in September 2026, the first time since January 2025. CNBC reported the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.37% as of late October. That raises a buyer's monthly payment on a typical home by hundreds of dollars compared with two years ago. Buyers feel it. That's real.

Average 30-year fixed rate, late October 2026
Source: CNBC, Oct 28, 2026

But here's what rates alone don't tell you: demand in Southern York County hasn't stopped. It's shifted. Buyers are pickier about price and condition. The homes that are prepped and priced right are still going fast.

Speed near the Maryland line

Stewartstown and Shrewsbury sit closest to the Maryland line, drawing commuters up I-83. These two towns had the highest share of homes going under contract within two weeks of any area in this market, according to the Real Estate Data Aggregator.

Homes under contract within two weeks, three months ending August 31, 2026
Stewartstown80%Shrewsbury78.6%Dallastown75.8%Glenville75%New Freedom73.3%York (17402)63.3%Glen Rock54.6%
Real Estate Data Aggregator, three months ending August 31, 2026. Stewartstown's share rose 30 points year over year. Shrewsbury's rose 20.7 points.

Stewartstown's 80% figure is up 30 points from the same three months in 2025, according to the Real Estate Data Aggregator. Shrewsbury's 78.6% is up 20.7 points. Those are big moves in one year. The demand is there. What changed is that buyers are less forgiving on price.

What sellers are actually getting

Pricing still matters more than ever at these rate levels. Look at what homes are selling for relative to list price across Southern York County towns.

Sale price vs. list price and speed, three months ending August 31, 2026
New FreedomStewartstownShrewsburyGlenville
Sale to list price101.4%101.1%100.6%100.1%
Sold above list59.4%44.4%55%60%
Median days on market5863
Median sale price$429,000$394,950$322,900$400,000
Real Estate Data Aggregator, three months ending August 31, 2026. Glenville's sample is small (5 homes sold); treat it as directional, not definitive.

New Freedom's median sale price rose 16.7% year over year to $429,000, the Real Estate Data Aggregator counted. Nearly 6 in 10 homes there sold above list price. Median days on market: 5. That's a market where well-prepared homes are still commanding strong offers.

The honest catch: some softness is showing

Not every number points up. In Shrewsbury, the median sale price fell 13.9% year over year to $322,900, according to the Real Estate Data Aggregator. Glen Rock's median dropped 13.3% to $338,000. In both cases, homes are still selling fast. But buyers pushed back on price, and sellers adjusted. That's what a payment-sensitive market looks like.

Seven Valleys saw median days on market rise 11 days year over year to 24 days, the Real Estate Data Aggregator reported. That's the slowest of any area in this market. Homes there are still selling, but the window is wider. Prep and pricing matter more, not less.

Hanover is its own market

Hanover operates differently from the I-83 corridor towns. It's oriented to Route 94 and its own commercial center, not the Maryland commute. The Real Estate Data Aggregator counted 235 homes sold there in the three months ending August 31, 2026, the largest volume of any single area here. Median sale price rose 8.3% year over year to $325,000. Days on market: 15. More than half of homes went under contract within two weeks.

Hanover, three months ending August 31, 2026
Homes sold
Largest volume in this market
Median sale price
Up 8.3% year over year
Median days on market
2 days longer than a year ago
Sale to list price
Up 0.9 points year over year
Months of supply
Down 0.4 months year over year
Source: Real Estate Data Aggregator, the three months ending August 31, 2026

Supply is tighter in Hanover than a year ago. Fewer homes for sale, down 21.4% year over year, with 162 active listings counted by the Real Estate Data Aggregator. That's keeping competition real even as rates bite.

The broader picture: 1,160 homes sold in one quarter

Across all the areas covered here, the Real Estate Data Aggregator counted 1,160 homes sold and 1,174 pending sales in the three months ending August 31, 2026. New listings came in at 1,326. That means demand is nearly keeping pace with supply. The Federal Housing Finance Agency reported U.S. home prices rose 2.4% year over year through August 2026. Local prices in most of these towns are running well ahead of that.

Southern York County and York area combined, three months ending August 31, 2026
Homes sold
All 14 ZIP codes combined
Pending sales
Demand keeping pace with supply
New listings
More homes came to market
Homes for sale
Active inventory across all areas
Source: Real Estate Data Aggregator, the three months ending August 31, 2026

What this means if you're selling

Speed is still there in Southern York County. But buyers at 7%-plus rates are doing the math on monthly payments. A home priced $20,000 too high doesn't just sit a little longer. It sits. The towns closest to the Maryland line, Shrewsbury, Stewartstown and New Freedom, are showing the strongest urgency. Prep your home well, price it honestly, and the data says it moves.

In short
  1. Rates above 7% are real, and buyers feel them.
  2. But in Shrewsbury, Stewartstown and New Freedom, 4 in 5 homes are still going under contract within two weeks.
  3. The market rewards pricing and prep.
  4. It punishes overpricing more than it used to.

One more thing: these numbers cover broad areas. One street in Shrewsbury can read very differently from another. A home on a busy road, or one that needs work, or one priced above the neighborhood ceiling, will behave differently from the averages above. The data gives you the range. Your specific home tells the real story.

Your next step

(443) 552-9815

Text me your address and I'll send back how fast homes like yours are moving in your part of Southern York County, and what they're actually selling for. Takes a day, costs nothing.

Text me
Where these numbers came from
Erin Kelly
Monument Sotheby's Realty · (443) 552-9815
Privacy policyTerms of useDo not sell or share my informationAccessibility statementFair housing notice
Erin Kelly is a licensed real estate agent with Monument Sotheby's Realty, license #MD: 651492 | PA: RSR004554. Market numbers come from MLS records and are believed accurate but not guaranteed. Nothing on this site is an appraisal or a promise of value. If your home is already listed with another broker, this is not a solicitation.
© 2026 Erin Kelly · Monument Sotheby's RealtyEQUAL HOUSING OPPORTUNITY